news

Surrogate-motherhood-from-a-legal-and-a-practical-point-of-view.pdf (more…)Close

The Constitutional Court on April 26, 2016 granted the constitutional complaint of a father who did not agree to pay an amount of 500.00 CZK to a medical facility as standard costs for his presence at the birth of his child. The complainant fought at the Constitutional Court against the general practice according to which fathers were without payment for their attendance at birth prevented from being present at delivery of their child in the delivery room, what the complainant regarded as a contradiction to the fundamental right of protection of the family. The Constitutional Court found that the applicant's rights were violated because the realization of his right to be present at the birth shall not be dependent on a payment of the normal operating costs of the birth clinic - among others costs for unique clothing and shoe covers –. The Constitutional Court also noted that the mere presence at birth cannot be charged with a payment obligation for the presence at the birth or the usual operating costs of the medical institution, since e.g. hygienic clothing, disinfectants, surgical mask or shoe covers, must be available in general for all those who are in the medical institution (also employees, personnel for transport and care, patients and their entourage or visitors. The reasons given for the judgment by the Constitutional Court also express the circumstances under which certain payments for the presence of a person at birth may be required, not to be limited to the child's father. In connection with the presence at birth, only those services can be charged with a fee that exceed the scope of the legal obligations of the institution. In relation to these services the person, however, must have an opportunity to comment on whether they are interested in the service or not. For certain services or actions that need to be made available due to its nature, then the payment can be demanded readily. However, payment must be reasonable and must not stand in substantial disproportion to the set-up costs, the necessary scope and in relation to the actual services provided. If a person refuses to a advance payment to be present, according to the Constitutional Court, this must not affect his right to be present at birth. An appropriate flat-rate fee is not unconstitutional, but the fee must at least generally correspond to a reasonable compensation. The generalization cannot be a means of veiled profit or replacement of health insurance revenue or be used as means to prevent others from sticking to their plan to attend birth. (Case - Case number IV ÚS 3035/15.)Close

On March 16, 2016 a workshop between representatives of the judiciary from the Czech Republic and the Federal Republic of Germany, on the initiative of the Czech Republic, held in Prague, in which both sides have discussed problematic issues. It was about questions being engaged by the judicial authorities in practice and currently hinder the smooth recognition and enforcement of decisions on fines or other financial penalties in the two countries. This working meeting was followed by the Czech-German practical workshop of the mutual cooperation on the recognition and enforcement of judgments on the basis of the Framework Decision 2005/214 / SVV of the Council of February 24, 2005 aimed on the application of the principle of mutual recognition of financial penalties, the representative of the Czech judiciary participated in this practical workshop on September 30, 2014 in Berlin. During the meeting the following issues were discussed: the recognition and enforcement of decisions on the repayment obligation of the legal costs, the effects of the judgment of the European Union, 15. 10. 2015 in Case C-216/14 Gavril Covaci on the recognition and enforcement of decisions of the German authorities relating to the fines or other financial services in the Czech Republic and other practical aspects of the application of the above framework decision. Taken from the press department of the Ministry of JusticeClose